New Suitors and Social Disasters: Chapters 13-23
This work was created in a different historical and cultural context. It may contain language, themes, or perspectives that are considered outdated or inappropriate today. We share it for its literary and historical value, while acknowledging that some content may feel uncomfortable or offensive to modern readers.
Pride and Prejudice Study Guide, Part 2
Deception and Social Ruin
This section of Pride and Prejudice deliberately complicates the social landscape with the arrival of two starkly different suitors: the obsequious Mr. Collins and the charming Mr. Wickham. Austen uses these characters to explore the theme of appearance versus reality, arguing that in a society governed by superficial judgments, true character is dangerously easy to misread. The disastrous Netherfield ball serves as the section’s climax, a public spectacle where the Bennet family’s lack of social discipline has catastrophic consequences, solidifying Elizabeth’s prejudice against Darcy on what she believes is irrefutable evidence.
Character Analysis: A Study in Deception
Austen presents Mr. Collins and Mr. Wickham as foils not just for Darcy, but for each other. They represent two distinct forms of social deception: one transparently foolish, the other dangerously seductive.
Mr. Collins: The Sycophant: As the heir to the Longbourn estate, Mr. Collins embodies the absurdity of a social system based on patronage and primogeniture. His character is a satirical masterpiece, defined by a comical mixture of pomposity and servility. His entire identity is derived from his patroness, the formidable Lady Catherine de Bourgh, whom he quotes incessantly. His marriage proposal to Elizabeth in Chapter 19 is a transaction, a list of pragmatic reasons devoid of genuine affection. His shock at her refusal reveals a patriarchal worldview so rigid it cannot comprehend female agency; for him, it is simply “usual with young ladies to reject the addresses of the man whom they secretly mean to accept” (Austen 71).
Mr. Wickham: The Charming Rogue: In contrast to Collins’s awkwardness, George Wickham possesses a “happy readiness of conversation” that immediately captivates Meryton society, and Elizabeth in particular. His carefully crafted story of Darcy’s cruelty is a masterpiece of manipulative rhetoric, designed to exploit Elizabeth’s pre-existing bias. It transforms her vague dislike into a righteous conviction. By presenting Wickham as a seemingly reliable narrator, Austen employs dramatic irony, leading the reader, alongside her protagonist, into a carefully laid trap of misinformation (Guerin et al. 110).
Key Scene: The Netherfield Ball as Social Catastrophe
The Netherfield ball in Chapter 18 is the novel’s first major social disaster, crystallizing its central tensions and acting as a catalyst for future events.
The Solidification of Prejudice: Wickham’s conspicuous absence, which Elizabeth interprets as proof of Darcy’s tyranny, poisons her already tense dance with Darcy. Their exchange is a masterclass in subtext, a verbal duel fought with veiled accusations and polite hostility.
The Humiliation of the Family: The ball showcases the Bennet family’s poor behaviour in excruciating detail, much to Elizabeth’s mortification. Mrs. Bennet speaks loudly of an imminent engagement between Jane and Bingley, Mary inflicts a mediocre musical performance upon the guests, and Mr. Collins introduces himself clumsily to Darcy. For Elizabeth, who prides herself on her intelligence and wit, her family’s public behaviour is a source of profound mortification.
The Catalyst for Separation: The evening’s events provide Darcy with the justification he needs to separate Bingley from Jane. The subsequent departure of the Netherfield party to London, announced in a deceptively cool letter from Caroline Bingley, leaves Jane heartbroken and fuels Elizabeth’s conviction that Darcy is the villain responsible for her sister’s suffering.
Charlotte’s Choice: Pragmatism vs. Romance
Elizabeth’s rejection of Mr. Collins is swiftly followed by his proposal to, and acceptance by, her close friend Charlotte Lucas. Charlotte’s decision is a moment of stark realism in a novel often defined by its romantic aspirations. She explains her choice not in terms of love, but of security, a pragmatic calculation from a woman with few prospects. Her choice horrifies Elizabeth but serves as a powerful social commentary on the limited options available to women of the era. Charlotte chooses a “comfortable home” over the uncertainty of waiting for a romantic ideal, a decision that highlights the economic pressures shaping even the most personal choices.
Discussion Questions
On Character Foils: Compare Mr. Collins and Mr. Wickham. How does each man’s approach to courtship reveal his true character and expose the different kinds of social and financial pressures faced by the Bennet sisters?
On Persuasion and Deceit: Analyze the rhetorical strategies Wickham employs in Chapter 16 to win Elizabeth’s trust. What specific details of his story are designed to confirm her existing prejudices against Darcy?
On Social Class: Mr. Collins’s identity is entirely defined by his relationship with his patroness, Lady Catherine de Bourgh. What does his sycophantic behaviour reveal about the nature of social hierarchy and the psychology of dependence in this society?
On Public and Private Selves: The Netherfield ball is a moment of public humiliation for Elizabeth. Why is her family’s behaviour so painful for her, and what does it reveal about her own pride and her awareness of social judgment?
On Female Agency: Charlotte Lucas’s decision to marry Mr. Collins is a pivotal moment. Analyze her rationale. Does Austen present her as a tragic figure who has compromised her ideals, or as a pragmatist making a rational choice within a restrictive system?
On Plot Development: How does Caroline Bingley’s letter to Jane in Chapter 21 function as a key turning point? Analyze its tone and manipulative language, and explain how it advances the novel’s central conflict.
Conclusion
By the end of this section, the novel’s romantic and social conflicts have dramatically intensified. Jane is left heartbroken, Elizabeth’s prejudice against Darcy has been cemented by Wickham’s masterful deception, and the pragmatic Charlotte has chosen security over love. The seemingly orderly world of Meryton has been fractured by misjudgment, social ambition, and carefully concealed lies, setting the stage for the explosive confrontations to come.
Continue -» The Proposal at Hunsford: Chapters 24-34
Return to Pride and Prejudice Index
Works Cited
This article was developed through an iterative collaboration between our Editor-in-Chief and multiple AI language models. Various LLMs contributed at different stages—from initial ideation and drafting to refinement and technical review. Each AI served as a creative and analytical partner, while human editors maintained final oversight, ensuring accuracy, quality, and alignment with AuthZ's editorial standards.